University of Leicester
Browse
d'Aniello C. - The jury on trial - Guilty or not guilty Investigating jury trial issues through a comparative approach_Author Accepted Version.pdf (181.96 kB)

The jury on trial: Guilty or not guilty? Investigating jury trial issues through a comparative approach

Download (181.96 kB)
chapter
posted on 2023-12-07, 17:22 authored by Cristina d'Aniello

In response to the democratic principle ‘justice by the people and for the people’, many jurisdictions worldwide choose to use the jury trial. European juries differ from Anglo-American juries and from one another in several aspects. However, despite the differences, none of the jurisdictions that uses juries seems to have found the ‘perfect recipe’ for a well-functioning jury system. The occurrence of miscarriages of justice involving incorrect jury verdicts demonstrates that the jury trial as a whole may be failing to respond to those democratic needs that constituted the foundations of its introduction. Nevertheless, the jury system appears to be ineradicably rooted in those jurisdictions that chose to introduce it. Clearly, the current situation calls for reform. This chapter, looking at juries from an international standpoint, proposes a critical comparative analysis of some of the most worrying issues occurring in jury decision-making contexts. As the chapter will show, in the search for solutions, comparisons at the international level can offer fruitful insights on how to promote improvement and reform of the jury trial worldwide. 

History

Author affiliation

School of Criminology

Version

  • AM (Accepted Manuscript)

Published in

Challenges in Criminal Justice

Pagination

47 - 64

Publisher

Routledge

isbn

9781003143321

Copyright date

2022

Available date

2023-12-07

Editors

Ed Johnston

Language

English

Usage metrics

    University of Leicester Publications

    Categories

    Exports

    RefWorks
    BibTeX
    Ref. manager
    Endnote
    DataCite
    NLM
    DC