'How I came to be a clinical psychologist': An explorative study into the experiences of becoming a clinical psychologist when from a South Asian background
posted on 2010-04-30, 11:54authored byDipti Pradumal Thakker
Literature Review:
A qualitative literature review was conducted investigating the training experiences of
minority ethnic students pursuing health careers. The review identified that various
challenges can be experienced by the minority ethnic student. The following themes
were consistently found across the studies: a fear of challenging culturally insensitive
practice or ethnocentric theories; being considered the cultural expert; a lack of cultural
competency by peers and faculty tutors; difficulties in balancing academic priorities and
family obligations; loss of confidence and motivation due to internalisation of negative
stereotyping. Recommendations include provision of a culturally sensitive pedagogy and
mentoring as supportive interventions.
Research Report:
Semi-structured interviews were used to explore the career trajectories of nine South
Asian clinical psychologists and analysed using Interpretive Phenomenological Analysis.
All of the participants in this study were the only South Asian in their cohort on the
DClinPsy training course; eight were the only minority ethnic student. Participants
described unique classroom experiences relating to their cultural identity including
feelings of isolation and being perceived by staff and peers as the ‘cultural expert,’
consistent with the literature. Furthermore, gendered pressures included balancing
academic and cultural responsibilities for the female participants. Socio-cultural factors
such as family expectations and a value for traditional careers within the individual’s
community posed challenges for choosing clinical psychology as a career. Participants’
descriptions of ‘being different’ to their South Asian peers suggest issues of self-identity
related to career choice. Once qualified, being a South Asian clinical psychologist
created subtle tensions when professional roles and responsibilities challenged cultural
roles within the participant’s own community.
Critical Appraisal:
Reflections in this paper consider the research process and the impact of the participants’
narratives on the researcher and of her personal and professional development.
Considerations are also given to the researchers’ impact on the project.